Ортағасырлық түпдеректер мен зерттеушілер еңбектеріндегі  Моғолстанның алғашқы ханы

Sergazy Akhmetkul; Umirbaj Bekmaganbetov; Kairat Battalov

doi:10.32523/2664-5157-2023-4-7-17

Authors

Sergazy Akhmetkul L.N. Gumilyev Eurasian National University
Umirbaj Bekmaganbetov L.N.Gumilyov Eurasian National University
Kairat Battalov Astana IT University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.32523/2664-5157-2023-4-7-17

Keywords:

Chagatai Ulus, Moghulistan, Mughals, Khan Esen Buqa, Tughluk-Timur Khan, Tarikh-iRashidi, Shajarayi Turk, V. Bartold, W. Erskine

Abstract

The article is based on the analysis of the domestic and foreign researches and examines data on the first khan of Moghulistan. Historians for a long time considered Tughluk - Timur to be the first khan of Moghulistan, which was created in the eastern part of the Chagatai Ulus. However, the works of British scholars of the second half of the 19th century refute this conventional point of view. Whereas V. Bartold, K. Pishchulina, V. Yudin, O. Akimushkin, O. Karaev and others justify
that Tughluk - Timur Khan was the first khan of Moghulistan based on the data of ‘Muizz al-Ansab’, ‘Zafar-name,’ ‘Shajarat al-atrak’ and other works, then British scholars W. Erskine, E. Oliver and N. Elias based on the materials of ‘Tarikh-i-Rashidi’ by Muhammad Haidar, ‘Shajarayi Turk’ by Abulgazi describes Esen Buqa as the founder of the state of Moghulistan. However, the relative accuracy of the data provided in ‘Tarikh-i-Rashidi’ and ‘Shajarayi Turk’ makes it possible to consider Khan Esen Buqa to be the first khan of Moghulistan. These arguments cast doubt on the statements of V. Bartold, O. Akimushkin and others about the anachronism of the data of Muhammad Haidar and Abulgazi Bahadur Khan regarding Esen Buqa.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Information about author

Sergazy Akhmetkul , L.N. Gumilyev Eurasian National University

PhD student

Umirbaj Bekmaganbetov, L.N.Gumilyov Eurasian National University

Candidate of Historical Sciences

Kairat Battalov, Astana IT University

Candidate of Historical Sciences, Associate Professor of the Social Sciences Department

Reference

Akimushkin O.F., 2004. Srednevekovyj Iran: Kul’tura, istorija, filologija[Medieval Iran: Culture, History, Philology]. SPb.: Nauka. 404 p. [in Russian].

Äbılğazy., 1992. Türık şejıresı. [Genealogy of Turks]. Almaty: Ana tılı. 208 p. [in Kazakh].

Erskine W., 1854. A History of India, Vol.1. London.Bartol’d V.V., 1943. Ocherk istorii Semirech’ja. [Essay on the history of Semirechye]. Frunze: KIRGIZGOSIZDAT. 104 p. [in Russian].

Karaev O.K., 1995. Chagatajskij Ulus. Gosudarstvo Hajdu. Mogulistan. Obrazovanie kyrgyzskogo naroda. [Chagatai ulus. State of Haidu. Moghulistan. The formation of the Kyrgyz people]. Bishkek: Kyrgyzstan. 160 p. [in Russian].

Qazaqstan tarihy (Köne zamannan bügınge deiın). Bes tomdyq. II tom., 1998. [History of Kazakhstan: from ancient times until today]. Almaty: Atamūra. 640 p. [in Kazakh].

Oliver E.E., 1888. The Chaghatai Mughals. Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland, New Series, Vol. 20, No. 1. P. 72-128.

Pishhulina K.A., 1977. Jugo-Vostochnyj Kazahstan v seredine XIV-nachale XVI vekov (voprosy politicheskoj i social’no-jekonomicheskoj istorii). [South-East Kazakhstan in the middle of the XIV - beginning of the XVI century. Questions of political, social-economic history]. Alma-Ata: Izdatel’stvo «Nauka» Kazahskoj SSR . 288 p. [in Russian].

The Shajarat ul-Atrak, or Genealogical tree of the Turks and Tatars. Tranlated and abridged by Col. Miles, 1838. London: Printed by J. L. Cox and Sons.The Tarikh-i-Rashidi of Mirza Muhammad Haidar, Dughlat. A history of the Moghuls of Central Asia: An English Version., 1895. Edited with Commentary, Notes and Map by N. Elias; The Translation by E. Denison Ross. London.Sultanov T.I., 2021. Chingiz-han i chingizidy. Sud’ba i vlast’. [Genghis Khan and the Genghisids. Fate and power]. Moskva: AST. 445 p. [in Russian].

Syzdykov S., 2020. Altyn Ordanyñ memlekettık ideologiasy. [State Ideology of the Golden Horde]. Turkic Studies Journal. V. 2. No3. P. 70-77. DOI: http:// doi.org/10.32523/2664-5157-2020-2-3-69. [in Kazakh].

Tarih-i Rashidi, 1996. Tashkent: Izdatel’stvo «Fan». [in Russian].

Sharaf ad-Din Ali Jazdi, 2008. Zafar-name. Tashkent: Izdatel’stvo zhurnala «SAN’AT». 519 p. [in Russian].

Judin V.P., 2001. Central’naja Azija v XIV-XVIII vekah glazami vostokoveda. [Central Asia in the XIV-XVIII centuries through the eyes of an orientalist]. Almaty: Dajk-Press. 404 p. [in Russian].